2015
9-5 Kent State 9-12 Western Illinois 9-19 @ North Carolina 9-26 Middle Tennessee
2016
9-3 Murray State 9-10 North Carolina 9-17 Western Michigan
2017
9-2 Ball State 9-9 @ South Florida 9-16 Western Kentucky
2018
9-1 Kent State 9-8 Western Illinois 9-15 South Florida
2019
9-7 @ Connecticut
2020
9-12 Connecticut
2021
9-11 @ Virginia
2022
9-10 Virginia
2023
9-9 @ Kansas
2024
9-7 Kansas